Greetings all, and apologies for group email.
Having reached a long-term goal a few months ago, I rewarded myself with a little break from monthly newsletters. I think it's time to get back to them, but on a quarterly basis. This bullet point format is meant to make the content easier to read and digest....feel free to let me know if that's the case and as always, I invite comments/questions, and I expect this will be posted on my website in a few days.
NOTE: Past performance is not a guarantee of future returns.
- The investing world has changed dramatically since early October. What had been a "buy the dip" mentality has become a "sell the rally" mentality, on the belief that global growth is slowing, that the Federal Reserve will continue to bump up interest rates, that financial conditions are becoming tighter, and that the "sugar high" of the tax cuts won't help earnings going forward. Signals of slowdown abound, from a flattening yield curve to select industries (autos and housing) and global economies, to drops in commodity prices. All of this is coming after a nearly 10-year rally, one of the longest in market history.
- To date I have largely stayed invested (client constraints depending), as I believe: 1) markets have 10% corrections somewhat frequently (once or twice annually) but unless there is a recession, they tend to regain their footing, and 2) broadly speaking economic conditions in the US are good. I don't expect 3-4% growth, but more along the lines of 2%.....not exactly a recession. Other countries' economies are growing at different rates, and have their own issues, but history has demonstrated that when the U.S. sneezes the rest of the world catches a cold.....NOT the other way around. All that said, the odds of a 2019 U.S, recession are increasing according to Morgan Stanley, which now puts the odds of one happening next year at 50% (Source: David Rosenberg, Gluskin Sheff Morning Comments Dec. 12, 2018).
- What's different this time is that the Federal Reserve is simultaneously raising short term rates and letting Treasury securities in their portfolio roll off, so there is more than the usual tightening impact. After recession, rising interest rates is at the top of my list of market concerns.....not to dismiss macro issues, they always exist, but predicting which ones the market will care about, getting the outcome right, and generating positive returns from doing so is not something I can do consistently. In addition, I don't believe I can successfully trade around headlines and tweets, and so my takeaway is to remain focused on what I believe the important trends are, to search for the right situations, and not to be distracted by noise.
- I believe the best chances for long-term investment success are in buying the right companies at a good price and staying with them over time, or as Warren Buffet would say, as long as they remain good companies. That said, I am careful not to "fall in love" with a stock or story, and to be mindful of the environment.
- I think the move to all things cloud/digital is still in the early innings, and overall I have a bias towards companies that are positioned to participate in that. Epam ("EPAM") and Globant ("GLOB") are examples of "digital ferrymen" who will have huge demand for their services and the biggest concern I have for them is whether they can hire enough good employees to satisfy that demand. Perhaps a revealing test of how this will evolve comes Thursday when Adobe reports....Adobe is the grandfather of the "SAAS" (software as a service) movement and as such is something of a bellwether for this theme.
- This is not to say that I own those types of companies exclusively. Abbott Labs ("ABT") and Independence Holding ("IHC") are the two biggest holdings across Peattie Capital portfolios and neither has anything to do with technology (except as a user of it). Being flexible, and a generalist, allows me to invest in a broad range of companies regardless of size or industry. ABT is a $130billion health care company which I noticed because the CEO bought $60million of shares a couple years ago and IHC is $.5billion insurance company.
- The recent volatility has brought valuations for many interesting companies back to reasonable levels. That said, in a recession, valuations will continue to contract. The potential for a meaningful (say 30%) drop in equity prices becomes increasingly possible, not just because of the lower earnings and lower multiples, but also because of the knock-on effects as individuals sell ETFs, which are in turn forced to sell their positions, which in turn induces momentum traders to sell, which in turn triggers algos to sell....it's a self-reinforcing downward spiral. Noteworthy is that in today's world the same holds true for the upside, with the net effect that the market can go to further in both directions than you might think...and probably faster too.
- Consumer staples (think McDonalds ("MCD") or General Mills ("GIS")) have been beneficiaries of the recent selloff, but are now trading at mid-20's multiples (the S&P 500 is about 15x) and over the past 10 years they really haven't grown much at all. I am much more interested in individual companies/securities than chasing the "flavor of the day" in terms of asset class, style, or geography. As Jim Grant says (paraphrasing) "successful investing is when everyone agrees with you later."
- In IRAs I have been much more likely to take profits as there are no tax consequences. However in taxable accounts, selling anything this year (well, almost anything) will result in material capital gains taxes next year, as many positions have appreciated significantly. Plus, doing so begs the question of when to get back in....which, if experience is any guide, won't feel comfortable until after a name (or the market) has bounced 30% off its low. The most successful accounts this year are ones where Peattie Capital manages both a taxable and non-taxable portfolio as I can reduce overall market risk by raising cash in the non-taxable account.
- I recently read (Grant's Interest Rate Observer November 30, 2018) that "in the year through mid-November, 90% of dollar denominated asset classes tracked by Deutsche Bank delivered a loss-the highest losing share since at least 1901....." Subsequently the article states "In the runner-up worst year, 1920, 84% of the then-37 monitored asset classes were in the red. In 1931, arguably the worst year of the Great Depression, 77% of asset classes made losses." In other words, this year has been remarkable in that there is nowhere to hide, and that broad-based diversification is limited and can be least effective when you need it most.
- Most recently Chairman Powell has been somewhat more dovish in his comments, and markets are now expecting a December hike and hoping for continued dovish commentary and a reprieve of some sort in 2019. Lately the markets have responded to every comment he makes, and I expect that to continue. Overall I would guess that if the 10-yr. treasury note doesn't rise materially above the 3.25% area (currently about 2.90%) that markets (indexes) are ok for the time being. Higher (and rising) interest rates are a clear headwind for equity prices as they provide a reasonable investment alternative, reduce market multiples, and generate a lower present value of future cash flows.
- Other things I'm concerned about: The market cap of the Wilshire 5000 is roughly $30trillion, about 1.5x US GDP of roughly $20trillion. This is an extreme level which has been this high in the past but never higher. (Source: Murray Stahl, Horizon Kinetics Q3 2018 Commentary). In addition, the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis reported after-tax U.S. corporate profits in 2017 of $1.8trillion which "marginally exceeded the 2012 level and was less than the 2014 level" (Source: IBID). Inflation has been reasonably tame given the tight labor market, but any uptick here could be problematic. It's difficult to come up with a strongly bullish scenario when valuations are this high, which is another reason I prefer individual security selection.
- 2019 Game Plan: KDWID (Keep Doing What I'm Doing). A few recent noteworthy items for Peattie Capital positions: The CEO of Howard Hughes ("HHC") bought $5mm of shares (two other insiders also bought small amounts); Mirati Therapeutics ("MRTX") expects to put one (of two) drugs into a patient in January; and DowDuPont ("DWDP") is about to split into three (Ed Breen, CEO, did this a few years ago at another company and created significant shareholder value). Also, and only for accounts that are ok with it, I have a few shorts, and I may add more. As far as shorting is concerned, it is very risky, and not for everyone. Short positions tend to be only 2% or so per name in portfolios where they exist.
Reminder that Peattie Capital manages separate accounts and so all of these comments are within guidelines established between myself and the client. Please feel free to contact me with questions or comments.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Taking a break, one more month - See you in October!
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Taking a break - See you in October!
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Pretty choppy in June
June was a pretty choppy month, with headline risk (tariffs) and some late-month selling. Most Peattie Capital portfolios
had a mildly difficult month, particularly those geared toward growth. The Nasdaq, at its peak, was +12% (ish) for the year and pulled back
to +9% at month end. So far, I attribute the dip to profit taking, and rotation into somewhat less expensive names.
Overall, the first half of 2018 has been terrific at PCM. Most portfolios
returned at least mid single digits net of fees and several gained low/mid teens. The single best performer gained 21%. The total return of the S&P
500 was approximately 2.7%.
Independence Holding Company ("IHC"), Peattie Capital's largest
position, dropped 10% in June, for no apparent reason (at least that I can see). IHC is tiny, and only a few shares trade daily, so I will apply the
same thinking here: that someone reeeeeally wanted to sell shares. IHC has gained 24% for the year, and I have no intention of selling it.
Not to pick on hedge funds (well, ok, maybe to pick on them), according to a June 30 Bloomberg article by Katia Porzecanski
("Einhorn Deepens Slide as Greenlight Plunges 19% in First Half"), the HFRX Global Hedge Fund Index "declined about 1%" in the first half of the year.
Several big winners in 2018, despite a pretty flat market
According to McAlinden Research (July 3, 2018) the top 10 performers in the S&P 500 were responsible for 122% of the index's
performance. To one degree or another, Peattie Capital portfolios own six of those 10 names (Amazon, Microsoft, Apple, Facebook, Google, Adobe). I
view several of the mega cap platforms as cities, and believe they can continue growing, even though several are approaching a $1 trillion market cap.
Other names that also delivered big gains in the first half included Texas Pacific Land Trust which owns
and leases property in Texas (+50%), Vail Resorts, which is buying ski resorts and expanding its EpicPass network (+30%), and Heico, an airline parts
supplier(+20%).
My point is that good stock picking can be effective even when markets, broadly speaking, are flat. By way of reminder,
Peattie Capital believes in concentrated portfolios with typically 25 (or so) positions.
Steady US economy
Q1 GDP grew 2%, slightly below the 2.2% estimate. I've seen articles calling for much stronger growth in Q2, possibly as
high as 4%. Not that I care tooooo much, as I'm more interested in individual stocks, but I think it is important to have a view on the overall
environment, and steady 2% growth is good. "GDP growth rate averaged 3.21% from 1947 until
2018, reaching an all-time high of 16.9% in 1950 and a record low of -10% in the first quarter of 1958." (source: McAlinden June 29)
All else equal, I would've thought the yield curve would be steeper than it is, or at least steepening....and it's not,
despite increasing oil prices and wages. In addition, the Fed continues to guide for more rate hikes, and I wonder what the "glide path"
for earnings growth will be, as recent earnings growth has been so strong. Good results with no market appreciation is somewhat concerning to me, and
my guess is that the uncertainty around potential tariffs/trade wars will continue to be headwinds for the market.
In addition, the current bull market is the second-longest on record, surpassed only by the bull market which began December
4, 1987 and ended March 24, 2000 (source: Barron's July 2, 2018), and also 2018 is a mid-term election year, which historically has been a difficult
period for the markets, at least until the elections are over.
Broadly speaking I am somewhat defensive, as multiples don't expand in times of uncertainty, fear, or rising rates.
That said, there are ongoing powerful and sustainable trends which provide investment opportunity (migration to the cloud, hyperpersonalization,
"as a service" business model for example) and also individual stocks which can "make their own weather."
18 years and counting
I wrote my first monthly newsletter in May, 2000, and have written one every month since, without exception. Most likely
I will switch to a quarterly basis.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
June 29.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past 12 months
showing an average return of 20.1%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 14.2%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
5/1/18 |
Apple |
AAPL |
Buy |
$165.28 |
$185.11 |
12.1% |
|
4/2/18 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$14.94 |
$16.53 |
11.8% |
|
4/2/18 |
Microsoft |
MSFT |
Buy |
$88.52 |
$98.61 |
11.9% |
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$16.53 |
(5.2) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$53.40 |
28.9% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$12.50 |
14.9% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$242.64 |
(0.4)% |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$47.04 |
$60.95 |
29.7% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$33.25 |
59.3% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$53.40 |
38.4% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 splits January 2018 and June 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stock:
There is no recommended stock for this newsletter
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Focusing on growth has been very successful
May was another terrific month for most Peattie Capital portfolios, and I attribute the strong performance to stock
selection. Several core positions delivered earnings above consensus and raised guidance, and shares responded favorably.
For the year, growth oriented portfolios are mostly up in the low teens, with the best up about 21%. Conservative portfolios
and those geared towards income haven't performed as well as growth, but most are still up roughly mid single digits. The total return of the S&P
500 is 2.0%.
The world is changing right before our eyes and I expect to continue to focus on companies that are leading or enabling those
changes.
Strong earnings growth...but, what's next?
Q1 earnings for the S&P 500 were up about 25% which was "far ahead of expectations" (source: John Authers FT May 9), and
the only problem I have with that is that it sets a very high bar for future earnings...which will not have the benefit of a recent tax cut. According
to the article, "the stock market has grown at an annualized rate of only 2.6% after quarters of 20% plus earnings growth." All the more reason to focus
on growth-oriented comopanies, as far as I'm concerned.
Late-month headlines about political issues in Italy were cited in the press for a selloff after Memorial Day, but as I've
said many times I am far more interested in finding the right companies to own at the right price than tracking macroeceonomic events and then trying to
benefit from them. Subsequently the yield on the 10-yr. note dropped back down to the 2.8% range, having started the month over 3.1%.
The next Fed meeting is in July, and I expect another bump in interest rates. Overall, I am somewhat surprised at the
market's resiliency....every time it looks like we'll have a correction, buyers come in and the market finds its footing.
18 years and counting
I wrote my first monthly newsletter in May, 2000, and have written one every month since, without exception. I can't say that I
enjoy the exercise, but I find it helpful to write a few words about what I'm thinking. For what it's worth, I am considering switching to a quarterly
newsletter.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
May 31.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past 11 months
showing an average return of 17.9%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 13.5%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
5/1/18 |
Apple |
AAPL |
Buy |
$165.28 |
$186.87 |
13.1% |
|
4/2/18 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$14.94 |
$15.45 |
3.4% |
|
4/2/18 |
Microsoft |
MSFT |
Buy |
$88.52 |
$98.84 |
11.7% |
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$15.45 |
(12.2) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$51.20 |
22.5% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$10.70 |
(0.3%) |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$252.07 |
2.6% |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$58.80 |
$76.05 |
29.5% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$37.15 |
77.2% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$51.20 |
31.6% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 split January 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stock:
There is no recommended stock for this newsletter
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Some very strong performers
In April the S&P 500 was flat and for the year it has dropped about 1%. Most Peattie Capital portfolios also had a
pretty flat month, and for the year most have gained low/mid single digits on a net basis. The best account has gained about 10%.
Two big performers this year are Independence Holding ("IHC"), which has gained 30%, and Amazon ("AMZN") which has
gained about 35%. Almost everyone owns IHC, which is tiny ($.5bn market cap), unknown, underowned, and underfollowed. I like it for its steady
earnings growth, its recent restructuring, its buyback program, and with
nearly $10 per share in cash and a rising dividend (currently $0.30 annually, up from $0.07 in 2014), the supporting fundamentals.
Only the more aggressive portfolios own Amazon, which with its $760bn market cap towers over pretty much everyone. AMZN
is still delivering above expectations and I believe it still has enormous runway in online sales, the cloud (AWS) and other industries where it is
beginning to make its presence felt, like advertising.
Owning such (apparently) disparate companies in the same portfolio demonstrates the power of good stock picking and
while neither will be completely immune from overall market risk, I have no intention of selling either one and would likely buy more should the
opportunity arise.
Still a "yellow flag" as far as I'm concerned
The litany of reasons to be cautious is pretty lengthy: modestly hawkish language from the Federal Reserve,
rising interest rates with the 10-yr. note just about 3%, inflation starting to percolate with Q1 PCE deflator accelerating to 2.5% (from 1.9% in
Q4), broadly speaking an expensive market (using Schiller "CAPE" P/E it's over 30x), and rising oil prices to name a few.
Two things that particularly caught my eye in April were 1) Caterpillar's CFO who said on the earnings call
"this is the high-water mark for the year" and 2) recent initial jobless claims of 209,000 that have dropped to their lowest level since
December, 1969, one month before a recession began (Source: David Rosenberg "Breakfast with Dave" April 27).
Rosenberg also states that "the odds of seeing a recession within a year when jobless claims are south of 250k are
over 40%...when claims are over 400k, by way of comparison, recession odds are a mere 10%" (Source: ibid).
In addition, Friday's +2.3% GDP report, while marginally ahead of expectations, was down from Q4's +2.9% and Q3's
3.2%, and consumer spending grew only 1.1% (annualized) from 4.4% in Q4. In light of the tax cuts, that is somewhat surprising to me.
Overall the markets remain choppy
A few other noteworthy items are the volatility we've had in 2018, the reversals during the day of both the indices
and individual companies (as much as I like AMZN, I was dismayed by the +8% opening Friday morning to the eventual +3% closing), and the fact
that investors (and savers) can now get 2% on a six-month Treasury bill and nearly 2.5% on a two-year note. To be sure those are not
mind-bending returns, but they are more competitive with equities than they have been for years.
Overall I remain cautious, and, while I'm happy to own my highest conviction names, on balance I think this will be a
year to be more defensive.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
April 30.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past 10 months
showing an average return of 14.6%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 10.8%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
4/2/18 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$14.94 |
$15.63 |
4.6% |
|
4/2/18 |
Microsoft |
MSFT |
Buy |
$88.52 |
$93.52 |
5.6% |
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$15.63 |
(11.2) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$47.15 |
13.0% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$12.65 |
12.9% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$229.42 |
(6.4%) |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$58.80 |
$72.15 |
22.8% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$35.40 |
68.9% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$47.15 |
21.5% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 split January 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stock: Apple (AAPL)
If I'm right about the volatility, I would expect the megacap names to outperform, and Apple (AAPL) (and March's
recommended stock Microsoft) are about as big as it gets. More importantly, they both have "castle-like" qualities. Apple has a large ($30bn)
and growing (20%) services component and slowing but steady revenue growth (say mid single digits). I also like the shareholder friendly
management and a below market 13x forward multiple.
AAPL pays a small dividend, and while I don't expect it to be immune from overall market risk, I do think
it will perform much better than most if things get rough.
I will use April 30 closing price of $165.28 for measurement purposes, but I
think it's OK to buy AAPL anywhere near these levels.
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Volatility returns
In March the S&P 500 dropped 2.7% and for the year it is down 1.2%. A number of Peattie Capital portfolios
dipped in March, but for the year most are still positive, with returns mostly in low/mid single digits on a net basis. A few are much better,
with the best gaining about 11%. Data on which returns are calculated is available upon request.
March was brutal, with big selloffs late in the month, particularly for growth-oriented names. Several core holdings
(Alphabet e.g.) and a variety of other tech leaders suffered significant drops after the Facebook privacy furor. Tech has been
a core holding in most PCM portfolios the past few years and several positions have more than doubled since I've owned them. While it's
tempting to take profits, doing so would trigger big capital gains, and over time I believe the names we own will be outstanding
investments. In addition, selling begets the question of when to get back in.
For the time being I think this volatility will continue as Fed's Chair Powell's recent testimony was mildly
more hawkish than expected, and Washington's unpredictability creates additional uncertainty. The two combined would be difficult enough, but
recently estimates for Q1 GDP growth have dropped from about 4% (as of February) to 1.8% currently (Source: Joe McAlinden Morning Research
April 2). Plus, markets have been exceptionally smooth lately (i.e. 2017) and usually periods of extended calm are followed by periods of
exceptional volatility...and vice versa.
In addition, a variety of indicators are flashing yellow, such as monetary growth and psychology. I've mentioned
several time the Buffett indicator, which compares the overall market value to US GDP, and it is currently running in the red (danger) zone of
approximately 137% (Source: Hays Advisory March 22, 2018)
As long as I'm at it, I may as well also mention that the calendar is somewhat unfavorable here. According to
Barrons (Feb. 5, 2018) "since 1950, the S&P 500 has been down 16.9% on average at its intrayear low during midterm years, though
the index tends to bounce back, posting an impressive 32% average gain over the subsequent 12 months."
On the positive side, earnings, broadly speaking, are good, and yields on the longer end of Treasury market haven't
risen. At some point that may be more of a headwind than a tailwind, but for now I think that is helpful.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
March 29.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past nine months
showing an average return of 12%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 10%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$14.12 |
(20.7%) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$42.85 |
0.6% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$12.27 |
9.7% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$246.46 |
(0.3%) |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$58.80 |
$72.50 |
23.4% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$28.50 |
36.0% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$42.85 |
9.5% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 split January 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stocks: MNR (yes, again) and Microsoft (MSFT)
I was tempted to re-recommend Monmouth Real Estate (MNR) again in March's newsletter, but hesitated as I have never
re-recommended a name so quickly. I've concluded that the 15% selloff in Q1 was one of those "baby and bath water" stories, as MNR continues
to be a hidden play on ecommerce with compelling fundamentals and an attractive 4.4% yield.
If I'm right about the volatility, I would expect the megacap names to outperform, and Microsoft
("MSFT") is about as big as it gets. More importantly, it is growing very quickly in the cloud (nearly 100% Azure growth) and its entrenched
Windows and Office franchises provide a leg up in upselling to existing clients. MSFT also appears to have pricing power as revenue growth
(for Offices) is outpacing seat growth. Other SAAS companies (Adobe, e.g.) have experienced significant margin expansion after converting to a service
model, and I think MSFT has more room to do so as well.
MSFT pays a small dividend (1.8% yield), and while I don't expect it to be immune from overall market risk, it is not
in Trump's cross-hairs, nor do I think it will be, and I think it is the right kind of company to own if things get rough.
I will use April 2 closing prices of each of these ($14.94 and $88.52 respectively) for measurement purposes, but I
think it's OK to buy them anywhere near these levels.
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Volatility returns in February
After a wild ride, with the S&P 500 dropping nearly 9% in early Feb., markets bounced back to close down 4% for the month.
Most Peattie Capital portfolios were basically flat, however a few portfolios owned Macquarie Infrastructure Trust ("MIC"), which surprisingly chopped the
dividend by 35%, leading to a significant drop in the share price. Owners of MIC have performed significantly worse this year as a result.
For the year, the S&P 500 has gained 1.5%, and the range of Peattie Capital returns is -3% - +10%.
Note that account performance varies based on client specific goals and constraints, and that past
performance does not guarantee future returns. Data on which returns are calculated is available upon request.
My takeaway from this volatility is that we are in a new environment.
The incoming Fed Chair has called for further normalizing rates, and the equity selloff coincided with a rise in the 10-yr. yield above 2.9%. Given
the tight labor market I would think wage-induced inflation might become a more real concern as is liquidity overall. And there's more hawkish trade
policies coming out of Washington, with tariffs on aluminum and steel. Generally speaking, I expect a more two-way and volatile market going
forward.
One other aspect of the market so far this year is that correlations seem to be breaking down. I would expect that
to favor active management, should it continue.
Strong earnings
On the plus side, earnings are coming in above expectations. According to Barrons (Feb. 26),
with 90% of the S&P 500 having reported, 77% beat expectations (normally that number is 64%) while 15% disappointed (vs. 21% normally). Earnings for Q4
are coming in 15% higher than Q4 2016, representing the third consecutive quarter of double-digit earnings growth.
In addition, revenue growth of 8% tops the estimated 7% consensus at the start of earnings season, and more than 75% of
reporting companies have beaten revenue estimates compared to 55% historically.(Source: IBID).
My favorite indicator, the shape of the yield curve, is still positive, absolute rates are still historically low,
and credit speads remain reasonably tight. If a recession were imminent, I wouldn't expect these to be the case. The second release of the Q4
GDP figures were essentially unchanged from the initial reading, dropping by .1 to 2.5% annualized growth.
Sentiment still too bullish
There's no telling if whatever correction we're having is over, but my sense is that there will be better buying
opportunities going forward. Usually some of the indicators relating to psychology/sentiment get a little worse than they did this time around.
For example, the Investor's Intelligence survey didn't get to the levels it reached in 2011 and 2016. Furthermore, after such an extended run,
most strategists/analysts I follow are saying that future gains will be lower than normal.
I continue to be very defensive in retiree portfolios with cash holdings as high as nearly 50%. For younger (or more risk
tolerant) clients I am ok with more fully invested portfolios. I have also been raising cash in most IRA portfolios. Taxable accounts are a
bit trickier right now because selling anything would incur significant taxes, and, I think the names I own will perform well over time.
Nowhere to hide
Why cash instead of defensive companies? One (somewhat) unique aspect to the current period is that traditional
"safe haven" equities have not been so so safe. Utilities and REITS, for example, have been poor performers this year, probably because of
more attractive fixed income choices. Likewise consumer staples, which usually see buying during volatility, aren't holding up well either. I
think each of these industries had been driven up to extraordinarily expensive levels during the recent run as investors sought yield. They
are simply too expensive today, with food companies (among others) also under pressure from ongoing internet disruption and changing consumer
eating habits. General Mills and Campbell Soup are prime examples.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
February 28.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past eight months
showing an average return of 8%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 13%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$14.12 |
(20.7%) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$42.85 |
0.6% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$12.27 |
9.7% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$246.46 |
(0.3%) |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$58.80 |
$72.50 |
23.4% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$28.50 |
36.0% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$42.85 |
9.5% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 split January 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stock: There is no recommended stock for this newsletter.
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
2018 picks up right where 2017 ended
The S&P 500 gained 5.6% in January and most Peattie Capital portfolios gained between 5%-10%. Note that account performance
varies based on client specific goals and constraints, and that past performance does not guarantee future returns. Data on which returns are calculated
is available upon request.
While I'm as delighted as anyone about this bull market, I am watching carefully for signs that a correction will happen.
Having gone an unprecedented 400 days without even a 5% pullback, we are due. (Source: David Rosenberg, Gluskin, Sheff Breakfast with Dave Jan 31).
Here are a few more recent Rosenberg tidbits:(Source: IBID)
- On Friday, Jan. 26, the S&P closed at 2873, and had gained 7.5% for the year in only four weeks-that level is the
Bloomberg consensus estimate for the entire year
- The savings rate, at 2.4%, has been this low less than 1% of the time in the past
- The unemployment rate, at 4.1% has only been this low 15% of the time in the past
- Last week's Investor Intelligence survey showed more than 5 times as many bulls as bears, the last time that
happened was 1986 (Feb. 1)
- At 18x forward estimates, the overall p/e ratio is higher than at the 2007 peak (Jan. 26)
- The 2.1x price/sales ratio is just below the 2000 dotcom peak (Jan. 26)
- The 3.4x price/book ratio has been this high or higher just 7% of the time in the past (Jan. 26)
Another of my favorite strategists/advisors is Hays Advisory and here are a few of their comments from Feb. 1
- "Our composite of psychology indicators...has fallen to the 5th percentile, a new record in euphoria for this bull market
and a reading only exceeded during the heights in 1999 and 2000."
- "As for euphoric headlines, this is a new one in the history of bull markets, 401(k) bragging on social media."
- "People are bragging about becoming 401(k) millionaires-and posting their balances to social media"-Marketwatch.com
Feb. 1, 2018
- Hays' proprietary return forecast stands at -2.4% annualized return expectation for the median stock for the next five years,
"which is the single lowest forecast we have ever calculated."
- "Bitcoin has lost almost half its value since its mid-December peak."
- "The energy consumed by the Bitcoin ecosystem continues to make new highs. A single Bitcoin transaction now
consumes enough electricity to power the homes of over 17 US households for a day."
Oh, and there's a new Federal Reserve Chair
Jay Powell, incoming Fed head, has not demonstrated the same dovish attitude as did Yellen or Bernanke. Just a year ago,
at a speech to the American Finance Association in Chicago he stated "It is not the Fed's job to stop people from losing (or making) money." (Source:
Rosenberg Jan. 26) Powell will be speaking in Congress mid Feb., and the next FOMC meeting is early March.
Interest rates rising
Meanwhile the yield on the 10-yr. note has broken above prior highs, and is currently testing 2.80%. I've stated repeatedly
that the extraordinary low level of absolute rates has been a tailwind for this market, and that if this trend continues (say to the 3%-3.5% range) that
will provide a reasonable alternative for investors and will draw investment funds away from equities.
None of this is to say it's time to sell everything, but I think it's prudent to be trimming and taking profits, especially in
IRAs where there are no tax consequences, for investors who have a short investment horizon, and for anyone who is sensitive to daily/weekly/monthly
fluctuations. Overall, if earnings continue to grow then equities can continue their run. However, there is no doubt that the list of challenges is
getting longer, and I think a stock picking approach has a much better chance of succeeding in this environment.
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
January 31.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past seven months
showing an average return of 16.2%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 16.9%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
1/3/17 |
Monmouth Realty |
MNR |
Buy |
$17.80 |
$17.09 |
(4.0%) |
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$45.10 |
5.9% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$16.75 |
44.0% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$248.03 |
0.3% |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico* |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$58.80 |
$65.85 |
12.1% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$29.30 |
39.8% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$45.10 |
15.1% |
|
|
|
NOTES:
Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited.
The risk of loss always exists, and past results
are not necessarily indicative of future results.
It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
* Adjusted for 5-4 split January 2018
|
|
|
Recommended stock: There is no recommended stock for this newsletter
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
2017 was a terrific year....now what?
The S&P 500 ended 2017 at 2673, providing a total return of approximately 21%.
Net returns for Peattie Capital accounts ranged between roughly 25% and 55%....needless to say it was a terrific year. Note that account performance
varies based on client specific goals and constraints, and that past performance does not guarantee future returns. Data on which returns are calculated
is available upon request.
I attribute Peattie Capital's performance to being heavily weighted in the right names. That is, names that were underowned
at the start of the year and then overdelivered on fundamentals
leading to multiple expansion. Examples: Align Tech ("ALGN"), the best performer in the S&P 500, which grew earnings
60% and the multiple expanded from roughly 30x to roughly 50x (source: Coburn Ventures "Valuations on our Mind" December, 2017), and Tencent ("TCEHY") where the multiple jumped to roughly 40x from a prior range of roughly 25x-35x (source: IBID).
To be clear, I do not expect similar outperformance in 2018, but I remain optimistic that over time good stock
picking provides a better chance for investment success than a broad-based and well (overly!) diversified equity portfolio.
Top 10 concerns going into 2018
By definition, I don't know what the surprises will be in 2018, nor do I know what the market will care about. However,
here are 10 "late-cycle signposts" (source David Rosenberg "2018 Market and Macro Outlook" December 29) which bear watching:
- Expansion turning nine in June
- Full employment
- Decade-low savings rate
- Cycle-high consumer confidence
- Fed tightening
- Flattening yield curve
- Excessive P/E multiples
- Very tight credit spreads
- M&A boom
- Peak autos/housing
According to Rosenberg, this backdrop is reminiscent of 1988, 1999, and 2006, each of which was followed by a recession about
12 months later. Among these, the flattening yield curve is foremost on my list. If the yield on the 10-yr. Treasury rises to the 3-3.5% range, I would
think that might provide something of a headwind for equities.
That said, bull markets don't die of old age, and the tax cuts have caused analysts to bump their estimates for aggregate S&P
earnings to the $150 range, which (if true) means the market overall trades at about 18x. Taken in isolation, that is not an egregious multiple, but it
is above the long-term average of roughly 15x. In addition, low absolute rates and inflation-free (well, inflation-"light") growth continue to provide
tailwinds to the market overall.
Note to self: multiples don't expand during recessions or in a rising rate environment! Or, put somewhat differently,
I think the "easy money" (if there is such a thing) has been made, and going forward, at least for now, good stock picking is going to become
increasingly important.
The "Buffett Indicator" flashing red
The "Buffett Indicator" compares the total market capitalization of all U.S. stocks relative to the
country's gross domestic product and it is flashing red:
"When it's in the 70% to 80% range, it's go time. When it moves well above 100%, it's time to tap the brakes. The
metric sits at almost 139% at the moment, which is getting awfully close to the record 145% it hit during the peak of the dot-com bubble in 2000,
the only other time the number has been this high, according to the Daily Reckoning blog's Jody Chudley" (Source: Hays Market Outlook November 16,
2017).
Stock picking is still a good way to go
Peattie Capital believes that paying the right prices to own the right stocks is a good approach
to the market. For some clients, depending on their specific characteristics, I might also overlay a tactical hedging program
to protect against material downdrafts which might consist of boxing existing long postions, shorting, or raising cash.
For long term investors, I (generally) agree with Warren Buffett's comment that "All there is to investing is picking good
stocks at good times and staying with them as long as they remain good companies." That is still the approach for most, not all, Peattie Capital clients
as difficult as it is sometimes.
Here is an updated version of recent Peattie Capital recommended stocks, using closing prices from
December 29.
This chart shows all PCM's recommendations for the past six months
showing an average return of 14.2%. The total return of the S&P 500 in the comparable period is approximately 11.3%.
Additional recommendations are available on request. This table does not
include speculative and short sale candidates which are only appropriate for clients who have requested
them.
PERFORMANCE OF PCM RECOMMENDED STOCKS
| Date
Name |
Ticker |
Action |
Price |
Close |
Gain |
|
|
11/2/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$42.60 |
$45.30 |
6.3% |
|
10/3/17 |
NGL Industries |
NGL |
Buy |
$11.90 |
$14.05 |
21.3% |
|
8/2/17 |
Broadcom |
AVGO |
Buy |
$250.00 |
$256.90
| 3.2% |
|
8/2/17 |
Heico |
HEI/A |
Buy |
$73.50 |
$79.05 |
7.6% |
|
7/3/17 |
Independence Holding |
IHC |
Buy |
$21.00 |
$27.45 |
31.0% |
|
7/3/17 |
Cogent Communications |
CCOI |
Buy |
$40.00 |
$45.30 |
15.6% |
|
|
|
NOTES: Gains include dividends. All numbers are unaudited. The risk of loss always exists, and past results are not necessarily indicative of future results. It should not be assumed that future recommendations will perform as well as past recommendations.
|
|
|
One recommended stock: Monmouth Realty ("MNR") and one speculation: Overstock ("OSTK")
I've recommended MNR several times over the past few years and it continues to deliver steady growth. MNR
has a close relationship with Federal Express
("FDX") and benefits from the ongoing expansion of ecommerce. For fiscal year 2017 (ended September 30) MNR grew revenues and net operating income 20%,
including a 99.3% occupancy rate for the year, and 92% tenant retention rate. In October, MNR raised the common dividend from $0.16 quarterly to $0.17
(yield: 3.6%).
MNR is very small ($1.6bn market cap), unknown, under-followed, and delivered a 19% total return in fiscal
2017, (compared to a less than 1% total return for the MSCI US REIT index in the comparable period). I think the tailwinds driving MNR are firmly in
place, and that it is a "best of breed" operator. Shares closed December at $17.80 and I recommend buying them up to that point.
Overstock is a bet on the blockchain technology. Its founder, Dr. Patrick Byrne, is somewhat controversial,
but I am a big fan and trust him when he says that blockchain is a better way to play the cryptocurrency craze than any of the coins (bitcoin, ethereum
e.g.).
Byrne has stated that he doesn't expect OSTK to remain a standalone online retailer in its current form much
longer and that he personally is looking
forward to focusing on crypto currencies and their applications. OSTK, through its wholly-owned subsidiary (Medici) owns a variety of blockchain assets-
some of which they expect to monetize this year.
OSTK is not for everyone and will be only a very small position in the Peattie Capital portfolios that own
it. I will use it year-end closing price of $63.90 as the
starting point even though a number of Peattie Capital portfolios have owned it the past several months and I reiterate that it is speculative.
Please don't hesitate to contact me with question or comments and just let me know if you'd like to be removed from distribution.
CLOSE THIS ISSUE
Previous Years' Newsletters
|